The Hidden Life of Trees

Posted November 22, 2017 by Denzil in Nature, Reviews / 3 Comments

The hidden life of trees by Peter Wohlleben
One StarOne Star
The Hidden Life of Trees by Peter Wohlleben
ISBN: 9781771642491
Published by Greystone Books on September 13th 2016
Genres: Botany, Essays, Life Sciences, Nature, Plants, Science, Trees
Buy on Amazon US | The Book Depository | Barnes & Noble | Buy on Amazon UK

I found plenty in The Hidden Life of Trees to make me wonder and to see trees in a new light. The connections which “make fungi something like the forest Internet”. The various ways trees exchange vital nutrients with each other. The use of scent as communication. The innovative ways that trees defend their leaves from predation. The methods trees use to intercept water. All these and other learnings I appreciated.

However, I found the book heavy-going and frustrating and was relieved when I finally made it to the end.

Great if you like pseudoscience

Wohlleben presents interesting hypotheses but often doesn’t back them up with scientific evidence. An example is when he talks about brain-like structures at root tips, and a mechanism to store memories and experiences. But where’s the evidence?

Some chapters seemed to come to an end before he could draw a conclusion. For example, he mentions three oaks that shed their leaves at slightly different times. This is seemingly because “the tree on the right is a bit more anxious than the others, or to put it more positively, more sensible.” He writes that “recent research has discovered something that at least calls into question the effects of transpiration and the forces of cohesion.” Great. But aren’t you going to tell us what it is?

A forest full of anthropomorphism

Beeches harass other species, pines resent competitors, mother trees have buddies. And long parts of the book are frankly quite boring. This is because he approaches many chapters in the same way. He introduces a topic and then goes through the list of how it relates to different trees. So first he talks about the oak, the beech, the silver birch, the Douglas fir, the spruce etc. When this device happens repeatedly it gets rather tedious. And most examples are western European trees with brief forays into North America. I would have loved to read more about Asian or African trees.

The Hidden Life of Trees does include gems of insight and knowledge. But for me, they are hidden amongst too much foliage.

One StarOne Star

3 responses to “The Hidden Life of Trees

  1. I bought a copy of this about a month back and would like to read it. It sounds interesting to me, though it’s a bit off-putting to learn that the author doesn’t do such a great job of presenting the research he mentions. I suspected it might be a bit boring since I lent the book to my bro and he’s taking forever to complete and return it.

Why don't you drop TheBookOwl a message?