Category: Reviews

A Complicated Pregnancy + Author Interview

Posted December 14, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 0 Comments

A Complicated Pregnancy by Kyle Roberts

I received this book for free from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

A Complicated Pregnancy by Kyle Roberts
Published by Fortress Press on December 1st 2017
Genres: Biblical Meditations, Christian Theology, General, Mariology, Religion
Pages: 192
ISBN: 9781506406251
Buy on AmazonThe Book DepositoryBarnes & Noble
Goodreads

The virgin birth is a much-loved story in the Christian tradition, but many theologians dispute the tradition of the virginal conception on both historical and scientific grounds.

A Protestant theologian, husband, and father, Kyle Roberts was growing unsure of his belief in Mary‘s virginity. So he set out to investigate the virgin birth from every angle.

A Complicated Pregnancy records his fascinating journey through the evidence and the myth, through history, biblical interpretation, and church politics. His conclusion surprised him, and it will surprise you, too.

A Complicated Pregnancy is an easily readable, well researched, logically presented and at times entertaining book. In it, theologian Kyle Roberts steps back from the accepted sacred doctrine of the Virgin Birth/Conception to do what many Christians consider sacrilegious. He questions whether Jesus of Nazareth was really conceived in Mary without the involvement of Joseph.

To “Question the Unquestionable” is a bold step. For a Christian theologian it could easily be a career death rattle. After all, as Roberts himself admits, Mary is “second only to Jesus when it comes to Biblical celebrities.”

Considering the angels from all angles

Roberts wades in fearlessly where other Profs fear to tread. He throws hot potatoes into the fire of debate, neatly skewers them, and hands them to proponents of the Virgin Birth on a plate, ready to digest.

He leaves no stone unturned: theological, biological, ethical, logical. Here are some of the issues he raises:

  • Why does the Old Testament lend no support to the traditional view of a Virgin Birth?
  • Why is it not mentioned at all in the earliest/first Gospel written (Mark’s)?
  • Isn’t it strange that Paul makes no mention of it anywhere in his letters?
  • Why did the early Church Fathers consider that a miraculous conception was not enough and that Jesus also needed to be miraculously delivered? (They suggested that Jesus’ birth was a painless and bloodless event that left Mary’s hymen intact).
  • If the incarnation means the Son of God becoming a true human being, how can Jesus be one if he wasn’t conceived like a true human being?
  • If Jesus was truly human, he should have had 50% genetic input from a female, and 50% from a male. Did God replicate DNA to mimic Joseph’s? Or create a human zygote from nothing, and implant it in the womb? (But then he’s even less than 50% human).
  • What does Luke mean when he writes of the Angel’s message to Mary: “The power of the Most High will overshadow you”? This wasn’t a request – and Mary was by all accounts a young girl of 12-14 years old. Could the account imply something like “divine rape”?

A wind of change – or a hurricane?

Roberts packs up his arguments with a strong concluding chapter. He gives a number of reasons why a new view on this Complicated Pregnancy can strengthen one’s faith, rather than let it blow away in the wind of change.

To be honest, “wind of change” is putting it lightly. Roberts has flung open both the door of Joseph’s carpentry shop in Nazareth, and a certain stable door in Bethlehem. Through these open doors he lets a hurricane sweep through, leaving nothing undisturbed in its wake.

What are the implications of A Complicated Pregnancy?

One implication for readers is that this Christmas, Baby Jesus in his crib might get some second glances and thoughtful looks. Or ministers might wonder why some of his congregation are stumbling over the Apostles’ Creed in church. But what’s wrong with that? After all, “You know that the testing of your faith produces perseverance” (James 1:3).

But is that the author’s intention? Let’s ask him …

Interview with Kyle Roberts

In trying to understand the conception of Jesus, how important is the fact that people of the first century had an imperfect understanding of human biology? Namely that the sexual organs of the mother contained everything necessary for procreation. And that the male (or in Jesus’ case, the Holy Spirit), merely provided a “spark”?

Assumptions about science (and in this case biology) inevitably intertwine with our theological beliefs. Beliefs about biology and procreation in the first century help us understand why early Christians had no trouble accepting a virginal conception as compatible with the idea of the incarnation.

For early Christians, it was very important that Jesus “took flesh” from his mother – that she contributed something of physical substance that would became the body of the baby Jesus. As the mantra went, “that which is not assumed cannot be healed.” So, Jesus “assumed” (i.e., became) human nature, so that he could fully redeem our humanity.

For these early Christian theologians, their understanding of procreation and biology posed no problem for the idea of the incarnation (God becoming human), because the removal of the male contribution wasn’t an issue. Again, everything necessary was already there in Mary’s body. God, through the Spirit, simply provided the spark that animated the flesh that became Jesus of Nazareth.

But now we understand procreation very differently; the removal of the biological father’s contribution creates a conceptual problem for the idea of the incarnation. How does the divine logos become a fully human male, without the contribution of a human father?

How would you respond to a Christian who suggests that their faith is anchored in the virgin birth, and that you are therefore threatening the very bedrock upon which their faith is based?

In A Complicated Pregnancy, I speak directly to that assumption, by arguing that anchoring faith in a doctrine like the virgin birth, is precarious and unwise – not just from the vantage point of history, biblical support, and science – but from the perspective of the theology of the incarnation itself. I would go even further and suggest that we not “anchor” our faith to conceptual doctrines, since faith is a personal trust in a living God. Nonetheless, when we discuss doctrines that should be considered essential for orthodoxy, I think we should stick to the incarnation itself – which isn’t actually compatible with a virginal conception. I’d say it’s even undermined by it.

Many Christians may be concerned that even questioning the Virgin conception/birth is “the beginning of a slippery slope.” Is this true? Will your next books by querying the miracles of Jesus, and even the resurrection?

This is an understandable question. I would agree with the implication of the question that, if the virgin birth is on the table for re-examination, all received doctrines can be as well – including the resurrection. But as I explain toward the end of the book, the Christian doctrine of the resurrection is not undermined by the idea of the incarnation. So, I don’t see there being the same kind of compelling theological reason for rethinking the resurrection, as there is for the virgin birth.

I’d also add that the “slippery slope” is often used as a scare tactic; a way of keeping Christians in line and discouraging them from thinking too much. But I’ve found that thinking critically and exploring issues like this, following evidence where it leads, doesn’t undermine my faith but broadens and deepens it. I suspect that for many Christians, faith has stagnated not because they ask difficult questions, but because they’ve been dissuaded from it, by heavily guarded doctrinal walls!

Isn’t a virgin birth essential for a sinless Christ?

It was for Augustine and many medieval Christians, who believed that “original sin” is passed along through procreation. Sin and sex has been deeply intertwined in the Christian imagination ever since. The virginal conception became the great interruption of original sin – protecting Jesus from sex and sin. But when you discard Augustine’s theory of original sin (as we should!), you no longer need a virginal conception to preserve Jesus from the impact of the sins of Adam and Eve. So, Jesus could be conceived through human sexual intercourse and still live a sinless, human life!

Leading theologian N. T. Wright, when writing about the story of the Virgin conception, says that people “believe the story not because of what it says about Jesus, but because of what it says about sex – namely, that it’s something God wouldn’t want to get mixed up in.” Can you comment on this?

This restates my previous point about Augustine. For a few critics who have contacted me already, this seems to be their main concern. How could Jesus have been conceived by human sexual intercourse? There seems to be an underlying skepticism about sex here – that it’s bad, and that the human body is inherently evil. These sentiments run deep in Christian history and they have resulted in all sorts of problems for us. But if we can recover a better theology of the incarnation, that might help us move past these “gnostic” impulses of Christianity that still plague us.

You write strongly that the traditional theology of Mary supports patriarchy, suppresses gender inequality and underwrites sexual and emotional abuse against women. Can you explain how?

This answer also builds on my previous one. Look, it’s clearly not the case that everyone who believes in a traditional view of Mary and the virgin birth is patriarchal and oppressive toward women. Nor is the converse always the case (that a liberal view of Mary will result in the liberation of women). The point is that, by and large, institutional Christianity has constructed a view of Mary which has been convenient for perpetuating patriarchal attitudes toward women; attitudes which idealize female sexuality (and virginal “purity”), which instrumentalize female bodies, and which value women primarily for their submissiveness and receptivity. For another perspective on Mary, we need only look to Luke’s Magnificat, which shows us a different kind of Mary than the one which tradition has often given us.

Thank you for your input Kyle, and I wish you well with A Complicated Pregnancy.

Kyle Roberts

One StarOne StarOne StarOne StarOne Star

The Friendship of Mortals + Author Interview

Posted December 10, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 10 Comments

The Friendship of Mortals is a wonderfully and lovingly crafted book. The writing is smooth; the sentences and paragraphs have a perfect balance; the characters are interesting, authentic and believable; dialogue flows naturally. The plot is based on a short story by H. P. Lovecraft, an American horror fiction author from the early 20th century. […]


Watching the Daisies + Author Interview

Posted December 5, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 21 Comments

This delightful memoir has a number of threads running through it, all of which the author skilfully weaves together into an appealing whole. Music is one of the threads. It beings in Brigid’s youth when she danced to Alan Freeman’s Pick of the Pops in the living room, to attending concerts of performers like Thin […]


Then She Was Gone

Posted December 2, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 14 Comments

This psychological thriller has more twists and turns than a box of paperclips. And I guarantee you won’t see half of them coming. The basic plot is that a teenage girl, Ellie, goes missing. The police decide she’s run away from home. The search is scaled down. But then, years later, Ellie’s Mum, Laurel, meets […]


The Christian Fallacy

Posted November 29, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 20 Comments

The Christian Fallacy is a well-written, generally easy-to-read, and thought-provoking book. Some people of course may deride it as “the work of the Devil”. Others though, perhaps of a more open-minded persuasion, whether Christian or atheist, are more likely to find it fascinating. In it Paul McGrane presents an alternative view of the origin of […]


La Belle Sauvage

Posted November 25, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 10 Comments

As a huge Philip Pullman fan, I was looking forward to La Belle Sauvage, but came away disappointed. Where has Pullman’s genial creativity that he showed so clearly in His Dark Materials gone? Where’s his unexpected plot twists? His fascinatingly unique, deep and rich characters? The brooding mystery? His political machinations? His sense of fun? […]


The Endeavourist

Posted November 25, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 0 Comments

We first meet the author in a London Porsche dealership, buying not one but two top-of-the-range models. We learn how he is a workaholic investment banking project manager at the top of his game, living in a five-storey house near Buckingham Palace. However, personal burnout, financial recession and a midlife crisis combine to leave him […]


The Betrayals

Posted November 24, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 0 Comments

The Betrayals is an excellent book that is a psychiatrist’s dream – or nightmare. There are not just one but two dysfunctional families. (“When it comes to the hierarchy of dysfunction, we reign supreme”). A serious Obsessive Compulsive Disorder. (“Mine involved six repetitions of actions that included checking the bedroom windows were shut, making sure […]


The Upright Thinkers

Posted November 24, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 0 Comments

How did mankind evolve “from a species living off whatever nuts and berries and roots we could harvest with our hands, to one that flies airplanes”? Leonard Mlodinow in The Upright Thinkers tells us. It’s an interesting, well-written and deeply researched book. A theme is that humans have consistently thought out-of-the-box. “Our creativity is constrained […]


Bury the Chains

Posted November 24, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 0 Comments

Six reasons to read this excellent book: 1. It gives a global overview of slavery, taking in all actors, from the UK, West Africa to the West Indies and the Southern states, and including France, Nova Scotia, South Africa and South America. 2. It sets the record straight. Abolition wasn’t down to Wilberforce working alone, […]


Charles Taylor and Liberia

Posted November 23, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 0 Comments

This is an extremely comprehensive, well-researched and readable book that will be of great use and interest to anyone interested in brutal civil wars that ravaged Liberia and brought this country – that was established with such high hopes – to its knees. Although centred around the life and activities of Charles Taylor, the book […]


The Corfu Trilogy

Posted November 23, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 0 Comments

The three books making up the delightful Corfu Trilogy are all excellent as stand-alone reads. They are the classic My Family and Other Animals, and the lesser known but equally good Birds, Beasts and Relatives, and The Garden of the Gods. In all three, Durrell shows his skills as a master story-teller and superb naturalist. […]


The Energy Glut

Posted November 23, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 2 Comments

This is an excellent book that deserves to be read, achieve best-sellers’ lists and made compulsory reading at schools and colleges. The authors don’t mince their words: “the human race is getting fatter and the planet is getting hotter, and fossil fuels are the cause of both.” With an easy style and credible statistics, they […]


King Leopold’s Ghost

Posted November 23, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 0 Comments

This book left me seething with anger. Not at the author – this is a historical biographer at the top of his game – but at his subject. I came to this book knowing very little about the colonisation of Congo, other than it was a dark stain on the history of Belgium (a stain […]


The Trigger

Posted November 23, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 0 Comments

In Sarajevo on June 28th, 1914, an unknown Bosnian Serb called Gavrilo Princip reached for his gun and pulled the trigger. In doing so, he assassinated Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria and his wife, Sophie, in Sarajevo. This action is the starting point of many books, because it was the catalyst that would lead to […]


Nature Cure

Posted November 23, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 2 Comments

Nature Cure describes well-known naturalist and author Richard Mabey’s recovery from a severe depression. We find him at the start of the book in bed, blankly gazing at the wall. Encouraged by friends and realizing the need for a change of air, he uproots himself from the family house in the Chilterns where he and […]


Meadowland

Posted November 23, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 0 Comments

This lovely book made me feel I was in the company of the author while he was walking around or sitting in his nature-rich meadows in Herefordshire for a year. I found myself laughing at some of his descriptions. “The river shouts with the abandon of a football crowd”. Bees feed on red clover stalks […]


Help!

Posted November 23, 2017 by Denzil in Reviews / 0 Comments

This is one of those books that needs a celebrity’s name on the cover to get it published and read. In other words, if the draft hadn’t have said “By Simon Amstell” on the first page, it probably wouldn’t have got beyond an agent’s first glance. However, we live in the Age of Celebrity, and […]